The Nth Room: “Sexploitation” in Cyberspace

A few months back, people were enraged with news of “Nth rooms”, South Korean chat rooms on the Telegram app where users illegally produce and trade sexually dehumanizing women’s footage. Telegram users often coerce many underage victims into abusing their bodies and recording them to be distributed among “clients.” Not only that, but perpetrators have also reportedly turned real-life assaults into online content[i], distributing sexual and violent videos of women. At least 260, 000 users accessed these chatrooms and paid with either cryptocurrency or videos of their own to be traded[ii]. Telegram is specifically used for this ‘business’ because of its encrypted messages, which is deemed safer for perpetrators. 

Coercing victims to abuse and record themselves is possible because victims were previously tricked into giving their personal details and nude photographs to the perpetrators under the promise of being given high-paying modeling or escort job—which becomes a bargaining chip to blackmail victims into obeying the Telegram users’ sexual whims, including extremely violent ones such as cutting off a nipple or carving the word “slave” into their own skin[iii]. Quoting one of the survivors, “He already had my face, voice, and personal information. I was afraid that he would threaten me with that information if I said I would quit.”[iv] This manipulation method also correlates to why many of the victims are underaged girls—after all, this age group is more prone to such manipulations. This particular point shows how this case runs deeper than sexual abuse or revenge porn. Under United Nations’ definition, this can constitute as a modern slavery since it uses elements of coercion to take away the victim’s freedom. What happened in Nth rooms also fits Gamez-Guadix’s definition of online sexual victimization (OSV): some type of pressure through the Internet to obtain unwanted cooperation or sexual contact and/or the distribution of dissemination by the perpetrator of sexual images or information of the victim against his/her will[v].

The Nature of Digital Sexual Violence

While the platform is new, dehumanization of women in cyberspace is not a recent development. Such cases are known as technology-facilitated sexual violence (TFSV), referring to behaviors where digital technologies are used to facilitate both virtual and face-to-face sexually-based harms[vi]. Image-based sexual exploitation and the use of a carriage service to coerce a victim into an unwanted sexual act—as happened in Nth room case—are among these behaviors.  Aside from these, revenge porn and the distribution of illegally obtained videos from hidden cameras have always been prevalent to sabotage a woman’s privacy and exploit them sexually. A survey by Goodson, McCormick, and Evans on Internet users’ behaviors and attitudes when searching for sexually explicit material online, found that 15.8% of their sample said that they had felt sexually harassed during chat room interactions, with more women reporting sexual harassment in chat rooms than men[vii].

What happens in cyberspace reflect sexual violence outside of it, where it is found that said sexual harassment disproportionately affects women both in extent and impacts, particularly young women[viii]. Regarding this, Nth room is all the more alarming because of how well-organized it is. Videos of abuse and dehumanization are sold based on ‘tiers,’ where the higher the price, the more obscene the content. Moreover, this platform’s system is reciprocal, where to gain access to these primary outlets, a user must prove themselves in a gateway chatroom by uploading their own sexual abuse content and sharing misogynistic comments[ix]. Not only limited to Telegram, the perpetrators allegedly have another, more secure online platform to share ‘high-tier’ contents.

It’s important to consider that sexual predators online are harder to identify since most of their acts are not carried directly. This sense of detachment between cyberspace and real-life consequences due to the anonymity facilitated by technology made it easier for perpetrators to carry out dehumanization more ‘easily’. But in reality, the impacts suffered by the victims are as real as sexual abuses that happened in real-time. It’s important to remember that in TFSV cases, both the victim and the authorities might never be sure whether or not the abusive and derogatory content still exists in the cyberspace, or whether perpetrators have downloaded them. The inability to completely curb this distribution often creates a sense of paranoia for the victims: they’re afraid to be recognized in the streets by one of the Nth room users, or worse, being targeted in real life by one of the people who possessed their online videos. Thus, the humiliation along with the trauma continues. Again, this is a specific feature of the cyberspace: what has been distributed through clouds may never be permanently eradicated, making such cases more concerning.

Nth room case and other extortion-based examples of TFSV also have another specific dimension of danger. Due to the blackmailing as the first source of sexual content of the victim, the cases might seem like a consensual thing since the victims send the content themselves. Hence, in handling cases like this, there should be a nuance to consider the element of coercion and intimidation the victims face to consider the complex power dynamics.

Providing safer cyberspace

Cases of technologically-facilitated sexual violence often end without proper handling and prosecution, including South Korea, where perpetrators often go with warnings or light sentences. According to government data, 3,439 people were arrested between 2015 and 2018 for creating and distributing child-related porn, but only 479 were indicted and 80 received jail sentences[x]. In 2019, 92% of the people charged with possession of child abuse images were given a fine, while those who produced the content are typically imprisoned for merely two years in prison[xi]. Meanwhile, in the case of Nth Room, Choi Ju-bin has been arrested and waiting for sentencing. His identity has been made public due to over 2 million people signing a petition to disclose suspects’ faces, which is rarely done[xii]. However, this doesn’t mean the Nth room case is over, in fact, the rooms are reported to still be up and running[xiii]. This problem is made more severe by the lack of cooperation from Telegram—an encrypted messaging app hosting the rooms—with the police, which raises the age-old debate between privacy and security when it comes to cyberspace.

On the bright side, following the Nth room case, on April 29, Korean lawmakers have passed the “Nth room” bill to punish perpetrators by increasing statutory minimum sentences for violent sexual crimes and new punishments for those who possess and watch illegal recordings. However, not every country already has this level of attention towards similar cases despite the urgency. Generally, there are still loopholes especially regarding preventive measures. States must set better regulations to combat this new and subtle brand of sex crimes, addressing current loopholes such as how to hold technology providers accountable in cases happening in their platforms. In this regards, it’s clear how the concept of cybersecurity must be directed not only to protect the state and its sensitive information, but also to protect individuals and their rights to be safe from crimes, since what happens in the cyberspace can transcend into physical violence or long-term impacts in real life. There needs to be a specific law to criminalize the spreading and possession of non-consensual sexual contents and law to criminalize the blackmailing aspect. 

Nth Room is only one reflection of how cyberspace can be a dangerous realm for women, especially young and underaged women. While states must take concrete actions, this also stresses the importance of parental guidance and responsible monitoring, since research has shown that parents who mediate online behavior have the most resilient children. To do this, parents must actively communicate with their children regarding the ways to be safe in cyberspace, such as recognizing signs of abuse and blocking users who make them uncomfortable[xiv], and educating them about the meaning of consent and privacy so they won’t abuse those of others.  


Author: Heidira Witri Handayani
Editor: Amelinda Pandu Kusumaningtyas


[i] South Korea’s ‘nth rooms’ are toxic mixture of tech, sex, and crime. (2020). Retrieved 2 July 2020, from https://asia.nikkei.com/Opinion/South-Korea-s-nth-rooms-are-toxic-mixture-of-tech-sex-and-crime

[ii] The Nth Room case and modern slavery in the digital space. (2020)

[iii]  Vitalosova, D. (2020). South Korean Women Appalled at Low Sentences for Digital Sex Trafficker. Retrieved 11 July 2020, from https://4w.pub/ring-leader-in-korean-digital-sex-trafficking-case-arrested/#:~:text=Some%20of%20the%20%E2%80%9CNth%20Rooms,run%20up%20to%20%241%2C500%20dollars.

[iv] The Nth Room case and modern slavery in the digital space. (2020). Retrieved 2 July 2020, from https://www.lowyinstitute.org/the-interpreter/nth-room-case-and-modern-slavery-digital-space

[v] Ga’ mez-Guadix, M., Almendros, C., Borrajo, E., & Calvete, E. (2015). Prevalence and association of sexting and online sexual victimization among Spanish adults. Sexuality Research and Social Policy, 12.

[vi] Henry, N. & Powell, A. (2018). Technology-Facilitated Sexual Violence: A Literature Review of Empirical Research. TRAUMA, VIOLENCE, & ABUSE, 19(2).

[vii] Goodson, P., McCormick, D., & Evans, A. (2001). Searching for sexually explicit materials on the internet: An exploratory study of college students’ behavior and attitudes. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 30

[viii] Henry, N. & Powell, A. (2018)

[ix] Lee, S. (2020). South Korea’s latest sex crime scandal is a blackmail ring streaming abuse on Telegram. Retrieved 2 July 2020, from https://qz.com/1824130/korea-shocked-by-telegram-chat-room-sexual-abuse-scandal/

[x] Lee, S. (2020).

[xi] Enos, O. (2020). As South Korea Cracks Down on Sexual Exploitation Online, More Must Be Done to Fight Human Trafficking. Retrieved 11 July 2020, from https://www.heritage.org/asia/commentary/south-korea-cracks-down-sexual-exploitation-online-more-must-be-done-fight-human

[xii] South Korea’s ‘nth rooms’ are toxic mixture of tech, sex and crime. (2020)

[xiii] Vitalosova, D. (2020).

[xiv] Keller, M. (2019). How to Protect Your Children From Online Sexual Predators. Retrieved 11 July 2020, from https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/07/us/protect-children-online-sex-abuse.html